Reliability · 29,282 MOT tests in 2025
Tesla Model Y
In 2025, 29,000 Tesla Model Y cars had their MOT. 15.7% failed first time: 25% more failures than the average car of the same age (12.6%). Its MOTs note suspension and tyres more often than the average car’s.
At a glance
How it holds up with age
Every car fails more often as it gets older, so each age is set against all cars that age. Typical mileage is the middle half of the Tesla Model Y cars tested at that age.
| Age at the MOT | MOT tests | Failed first time | All cars that age | Typical mileage |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 0–2 yearsRegistered 2023–2025 | 1,411 | 8.6% | 7.3% | 30,268–71,260 miles |
| 3–5 yearsRegistered 2020–2022 | 27,871 | 16% | 12.8% | 24,322–45,148 miles |
Tesla Model Y common problems: its weak spots
How often each part was noted at the MOT, failures and advisories together, per 100 tests, against the average car of the same age. The line in the middle of each bar is that average.
- Suspension19 per 100 MOTs · average 6.1207% more
- Tyres76 per 100 MOTs · average 4377% more
- Lights and electrics2.5 per 100 MOTs · average 551% fewer
- Brakes9.7 per 100 MOTs · average 2052% fewer
- Steering0.1 per 100 MOTs · average 0.684% fewer
In its favour: lights and electrics, brakes and steering come up less often than on the average car of the same age.
What to check when you view a used Tesla Model Y
- Suspension: Listen for knocks over bumps on the test drive, look for uneven tyre wear, and ask for invoices for suspension work.
- Tyres: Check the tread on every tyre, inner edges included, and that the tyres match across each axle.
- Its own record: these figures describe the model. Every car is different, so read the one you’re looking at’s MOT history and mileage readings before you go.
- Finance and write-offs: the MOT record doesn’t show outstanding finance, a write-off or a theft record. A History check does.
Collision involvement
For every licensed Tesla Model Y, DfT records 35% fewer reported injury collisions than for the average licensed car (729 involvements, 2021–2025).
It counts collisions, not fault, and says nothing about how well the car protects you in one (Euro NCAP tests that). Cars that cover more miles, private hire cars among them, are involved in more.
How we worked it out
From DVSA’s anonymised MOT data for 2025: every first MOT test of the year on a Tesla Model Y (retests aren’t counted again), grouped by fuel and age. A failure includes a car that passed only after defects were put right at the station, as DVSA counts it. Each age is set against every car tested at that age, then weighted by how many were tested at each age, so a model with more older cars isn’t marked down for their age.
It describes the model, never a particular car. Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0 (DVSA and DfT). Our methodology